Staff Writer- Nhi Le
The holiday season usually brings thoughts of roaring fireplaces, falling snow and peaceful family gatherings. But inside the Evan & Evelyn Anderson Theatre, the most wonderful time of the year is about to be interrupted by a cold-blooded murder. This November, the Gustavus Department of Theatre and Dance is trading silent nights for suspenseful twists in their upcoming production of Ken Ludwig’s The Game’s Afoot or Holmes for the Holidays.
The play transports audiences back in time to follow Broadway star William Gillette, who invites his castmates to his expansive Connecticut castle for a weekend of revelry. When a guest is unexpectedly stabbed to death, the isolated house of tricks and mirrors turns incredibly dangerous. Gillette, who believes himself to possess the deductive skills of Sherlock Holmes, takes it upon himself to track down the killer before the police can intervene.
While the premise sounds grim, the production offers a perfect balance of intense suspense and sharp comedy. Guest Director Michael Swanson noted that the play was specifically chosen to connect with the theatre season’s overarching theme of fate and death.
“To be sure, this is a relatively comic look at the topic,” Swanson said. “The humorous treatment of the topic should be a welcome respite for students working on the second half of fall term.”
Swanson, a longtime fan of Sherlock Holmes and theatre history scholar, has enjoyed introducing his students to both the fictional detective and his real-life portrayer. He noted that the play provides excellent training for Gustavus theatre students in a wide variety of skills including comic acting, melodramatic pacing, stage combat and stage intimacy. Throughout the rehearsal process, the cast has learned how to safely manipulate weapons and transition deftly between comedy and highly serious moments like a medium’s seance on a stormy December night.
Bringing the eccentric lead character to life is Senior Theatre Performance and Computer Science double major Timothy Snyder. Snyder found a unique personal connection to the historical figure he portrays. He noted that the real William Gillette was the first actor to adapt the famous Sherlock Holmes character for the stage with the direct permission of creator Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.
“Mr. Gillette was a real person and it’s interesting for me balancing a portrayal of the real him and the requirements of his character in the show,” Snyder said. “He involved himself in theater but also had a fascination with technology and gizmos, which is amusing since that’s not unlike myself as seen by my double major.”
Joining him on stage is Sophomore Theatre Performance and Psychological Science double major Mira Paul, who plays the outspoken columnist and theater critic Daria Chase.
“Daria is an incredibly distinct character,” Paul said. “She knows who she is and she’s not afraid to show it. She is very sensual, whimsical and powerful.”
Because her character frequently speaks her mind in her column, Daria is not well-liked by the rest of the guests at the castle. However, Paul focused on looking past the abrasive exterior to find the psychological depth within her role.
“What has been important to me is finding her humanity and understanding the way that she thinks,” Paul said. “In theater there is not good and bad, it is not so black and white. Each character has depth and a life story that informs who they are.”
Finding the right tone for a script that is both deadly and hilarious proved to be an early challenge. Both Snyder and Paul admitted that the cast experienced many fits of uncontrollable laughter during the rehearsal process. Paul noted that maintaining the suspense requires actors to fully embrace “the illusion of the first time” so that every reaction feels completely authentic and keeps the show living and moving.
Behind the scenes, the student production team has been working to heighten this atmosphere of historical intrigue. Senior Classical Languages and Theatre Honors in Performance double major Rebekah Moll serves as the student director. Moll found great reward in problem-solving complex blocking issues and emphasizing small textual details to build the play’s eerie mood.
“What makes this show a must-see is that the twists and turns of the show, while unexpected, still allow the audience to deduce along with the characters and be drawn into the mystery alongside them,” Moll said.
The immersive mystery is further enhanced by highly complex technical elements. Junior Theatre Design & Technology major Sander Klotzbach stepped in as stage manager mid-production. He credits the dedication of the entire team, giving a special shoutout to Sophomore and Assistant Stage Manager Alec Vatter for keeping the production anchored during the difficult transition. According to Klotzbach, the isolated castle setting requires intricate coordination between actors and technicians.
“There are a lot of both practical and prerecorded visual and sound effects that are used in very clever ways throughout this show,” Klotzbach said. “I have to give verbal cues over my headset for off-stage police whistles, otherworldly knocks on a table, rotating bookcases and other such nonsense as well as each and every lighting shift and sound effect.”
As the winter chill begins to settle over campus, there is no better place to escape the cold than inside a Connecticut castle filled with hidden doors, rotating bookcases and a killer on the loose. The Game’s Afoot or Holmes for the Holidays runs from Thursday, Nov. 5 through Saturday, Nov. 7 at 7:30 p.m. with a final matinee on Sunday, Nov. 8 at 2:00 p.m. at the Evan & Evelyn Anderson Theatre. Whether you come for the mind-bending mystery or the side-splitting comedy, this is one holiday party you will want to RSVP to before the curtain falls.