Staff Writer- Evangelyn Hill
One of the most controversial issues of our time is that of artificial intelligence (AI): how should we use it? Should we use it at all? Can we lower the environmental impact? At Gustavus, faculty and staff are grappling with how the school as an institution should implement AI.
Director of Instructional Technologies Marni Dunning and Instructor and Digital Arts Librarian Rachel Flynn recently led a group that developed Gustavus’s Guiding Principles for the Responsible Use of AI. While it is not official policy, the document has provided the college with a basis for choosing how much artificial intelligence to use.
Dunning explained that these principles include “human-centered learning” and “integrity.” “These principles aren’t meant to discourage AI use. Quite the opposite! They encourage us to explore AI’s possibilities while keeping our Gustavus values at the heart of what we do,” Dunning emphasized.
Both Dunning and Flynn have seen fellow staff and faculty using AI in their work. “I’ve seen growing interest in using AI to brainstorm, summarize information, and simplify everyday tasks,” Dunning explained. She also uses AI herself “almost every day… It doesn’t replace my knowledge or do my job for me, but it helps me work more efficiently and spend more time doing what I enjoy most — helping people!”
Flynn pointed out that the situation is more nuanced, however. “One thing that we’ve learned from the various surveys that I have been part of writing and deploying is that AI use is incredibly varied across roles on campus. Sentiments around that use are also varied,” Flynn said. She explained that while she extensively reads research and news coverage on AI, she does not “actively seek out to use AI in day-to-day tasks.”
This dichotomy – of those embracing AI and those more skeptical of it – is playing out across staff departments at Gustavus. Assistant Director of Health Services Nissa Fell reported that Health Services is beginning to integrate AI into multiple areas of their work.
“Health Service has started to use an AI platform called Open Evidence… It provides answers directly from peer-reviewed medical literature and clinical guidelines, and provides complete source citations for every response. It also has an ambient listening tool which records the provider/patient conversation and helps create appropriate documentation, coding, and billing,” Fell said. She and the other Health Services employees have found Open Evidence to be helpful: “It has been a time saver, while accurately depicting the conversation between the provider and patient,” Fell said.
She also has found that students have been pleased with how Health Services is utilizing AI. “I think they are excited about AI and when it is a tool that can help create an accurate medical record for them, they are very willing to have it incorporated into their care in Health Services,” Fell said.
Not all Gustavus students are thrilled with all areas of Gustavus’s institutional AI use. An anonymous student pointed out that Admissions and Marketing may have used AI to create art for a pamphlet for prospective students, art which also appears on the “Stack Your Passions” banner in the Campus Center, and that this AI use was unethical.
“In my personal opinion, I do not feel that AI art is a proper representation of our liberal arts community. As a student employee, we are told to emphasize that Gusties are creative, intelligent, and those who ‘do it all.’ Why not take the opportunity to work with a Gustavus student, and use a soulless robot to represent our campus community that knows nothing about it?” the anonymous student said. The Marketing department was unable to provide answers at this time, so it is unconfirmed whether the pamphlet and banner art was AI-generated.
While some students are skeptical, many staff members are cautiously enthusiastic about adopting AI in their work. Assistant Provost of Faculty Development and Support David Stamps stated that he does use AI in his work. “The way that I use it mostly right now is organizing information… Google Gemini has a Notebook AI application, and I use it to put different bundles of policies or our handbooks within a closed box, so that I can query it, ask for references,” Stamps said. “It helps me find things quickly so when I need to respond to my colleagues I can find the info and reference it back to them. I like that it keeps things within that particular bubble, so that it’s not… hallucinating or finding things that are not actually part of our closed system.”
Chief Technology Officer at Gustavus Jerry Nowell uses AI in some very limited ways in his work. “Occasionally if I need a framework for a document I’m thinking of, and I’m wanting to get a different idea of how this could be organized… I don’t ever really use it to write everything from start to finish, mostly for idea generation or troubleshooting problematic areas of writing,” Nowell explained.
As for Gustavus Technology Services as a whole, Nowell reported that attitudes toward AI have been mixed. “GTS is kind of similar to the campus as a whole, where we have people here who want nothing to do with it… probably the majority are using it occasionally to expedite their normal work, and then we have a few people that use it for coding, but mostly just the coding prompts and things like that, again trying to speed up their existing work. I don’t think we have a heavy reliance on it,” Nowell said.
Both Stamps and Nowell recognized that students have very strong, active opinions on AI. “When I met with Student Senate, that was one of my biggest takeaways – how intelligent students are on this topic, and how involved they want to be on this,” Stamps said.
“I’ve been really thrilled to see how Gustavus has responded to [AI] – I wouldn’t say that our responses have been 100% right every time, but I’ve been really happy to see students as engaged as they are in the process, having strong opinions on AI,” Nowell said.