Title IX Panel Addresses Student Concerns

Staff Writer- Evangelyn Hill

The United States has recently been embroiled in a wave of concerns over sexual misconduct at colleges, sparked by an incident at Cornell University. In response to these concerns, Gustavus hosted a panel to inform the campus on the process of Title IX investigations. 

Title IX is a federal bill that prevents discrimination based on gender, and it also covers sexual harassment or misconduct on university campuses. The college investigation process is especially focused on privacy, which can make it difficult for students to fully understand how it works. In an attempt to remedy that, Gustavus Title IX coordinator Amy Pehrson collaborated with Student Senate to host a panel discussion open to the campus, which took place last week. 

Senior and Co-President of Student Senate Laura Sunnarborg helped to arrange the panel, alongside the new Title IX Ad-Hoc committee within the Senate. 

“It was shocking to me that one in five college women will experience sexual harm during their time in undergrad and one in fifteen men will… I believe that one incident of sexual misconduct is too much and we should strive for zero because sexual violence is completely unacceptable and extremely harmful and destructive…” Sunnarborg said. “I believe the Title IX Coordinator has a strict set of federal guidelines determining what she can do, but I believe she is handling the issues as well as she can, and the services we have on campus are also working hard to make students feel supported.”

Panelists came from on and off-campus, including members of Gustavus’s Sexual Assault Response Team (SART), an advocate from the Mankato advocacy group Committe Against Domestic Assault (CADA), and from the local police and attorney’s office. Senior Natasha Grad moderated the discussion.

Early in the panel discussion, Grad asked the panelists to clarify what Title IX is and how the process works. Pehrson explained that Title IX is a federal policy enacted in 1972 and as Gustavus is federally funded, the college is required to follow the policy’s legal framework. That framework is a long and careful process designed to protect the privacy of the students involved and to find the truth of the situation in a fair way.

Pehrson set up a hypothetical situation to illustrate the process. “Let’s just say somebody experienced something, they’re not sure what exactly it was,” Pehrson began. “Maybe somebody on campus knows about it, and some of those folks we call mandated reporters… the folks on campus that are obligated to report what they know… they need to file a Title IX report. That comes in to me, and I look at that report, identify the person who is in that report, and reach out to them as quickly as I can…”

After that initial incident report, the students Pehrson contacts have the choice whether or not to meet with her. Some students simply delete the email or never respond; some students are eager to continue the discussion with Pehrson. If the student does decide to continue, Pehrson first makes sure the student has the support they need.

“I don’t necessarily start with what happened,” Pehrson said, “but I start with ‘are you ok, is there anything you need?’ Maybe we need to call Health Services, or walk down to the Counseling Center. Do you want to contact law enforcement, do you need to leave your room for the weekend, do you need to go home?” 

At this stage (and all other stages of the process), students are also supported by SART and CADA. Member of CADA Julia Hamann explained that CADA advocates work with community members who have experienced sexual harassment. 

“I think of an advocate as kind of a cheerleader or teammate, someone who is in your corner,” Hamann explained. “They’re there to provide info to make informed decisions as to what you want to do moving forward, and walk beside you through whatever process you choose… we do have legal advocacy, we have someone who can be there when a SA examination is being done, we can go with you to court… and we provide emotional support as well.”

Member of Gustavus SART Jill VanOsdol said that SART is the on-campus equivalent to CADA who you can call for advice or assistance. “CADA is our backup if we’re all gone on holiday,” VanOsdol explained. 

Throughout all this, the SART team stressed that it’s important for the student to drive the process. If the student does decide to continue the investigation, Pehrson will initiate the investigation phase, working with an outside firm to contact the alleged perpetrator, interview witnesses, and gather all the evidence into a report. Finally, there is a live hearing over a video call, so that the students can remain in separate rooms.

“There is a hearing panel of faculty and staff who have been trained to hear these cases and have reviewed all the evidence and reports. Then they make the determination as to if there has been a violation, and if so, what the sanctions will be… there’s an appeal process, and once that timeframe is over, the sanctions go into effect,” Pehrson explained.

The Title IX office stated that students are carefully supported through the long process. As the neutral party in the process, Pehrson cannot penalize students before a verdict is reached. She can, however, put “supportive measures” in place, such as requiring the students involved to enter dorms through separate doors so they avoid contact, or working with faculty to ensure the two students are not in group projects together. 

The college Title IX process is separate from a police investigation or a criminal charge. A student may or may not decide to pursue criminal charges during or after their Title IX investigation. 

If they do choose to contact the police, the case will likely go to Detective Bill Gerhart of the St. Peter Police Department, who has worked with the police for sixteen years and helped coordinate the St. Peter police response to sexual assault. 

“As law enforcement, we’re the initiation of that criminal investigation… We want to hopefully hold someone accountable, which will take investigation, interviews, and evidence… Our goal is to charge someone criminally and then hand that case over to Michelle for prosecution,” Gerhart said. 

Michelle Zehnder Fischer is the Nicollet County Attorney. Her office handles gross misdemeanors or felonies of domestic violence or sexual assault. She is the last step in the process, should a student press charges against their perpetrator. 

The County Attorney’s office can start two processes: the actual criminal prosecution in court, and a civil court domestic violence protection order. “That is a separate process from the criminal process… the civil process is an independently legally enforceable order. So while Amy [Pehrson] doesn’t have the ability to say you can’t be in the same class together, the court could,” Fisher said. 

Throughout the Title IX process, Gustavus students are supported at each step by Gustavus administrators, campus SART members, off-campus CADA advocates, and the Nicollet County police and attorney’s offices. While the process is long and difficult, it is designed to protect survivors and bring perpetrators to justice. 

Leave a Reply